ஹரியோடு நான் அப்படீன்னு ஒரு நிகழ்ச்சி.. ஜெயா டிவில ஓடிட்டு இருக்கு..இதுல ஒரு நடுவரா வாறாரு நம்ம ஜேம்ஸ் வசந்தன்..
சில தடவ சேனல் மாத்துரப்ப இந்த ப்ரோக்ராம் பார்த்து இருக்கேன்.. பார்த்து அதிசய பட்டு இருக்கேன்.. காரணம் இதுல வர்ற நடுவர்கள்.. முக்கியமா நம்ம வசந்தன்..
இது வரைக்கும் 100 படத்துக்கும் மேல இசை அமைச்சு இருகாரு .. 25 FILM FARE AWARD வாங்கி இருகாரு, 4 ஆஸ்கார் AWARD வாங்கி இருக்காறு 10 தமிழ்நாடு அரசு அவரது, 3 நேஷனல் AWARD வாங்கி இருகார்..
இவ்ளோ இருந்தும் ஒரு வார்த்தை கூட அடுத்தவங்க மனசு புண் படுற மாதிர பேசுறது இல்ல.. பாட வர்றவங்கள ரொம்ப மரியாதையா பேசுறாரு..
அவர நடுவரா வந்த பார்க்க அவ்ளோ சந்தோசமா இருக்கு.. இவர் மாதிரி வேற ஒரு நடுவர் வரவே முடியாது.. இசை சக்கரவர்த்தி இவர்.. அதைவிட நல்லா மனிதர்.. அடுத்தவர்களை மனம் நோகதபடி அன்போடு அறிவுரை வழங்குகிறார்..
வாழ்க அவரது நடுவர் பணி...
1997 ம் வருஷம் " பகைவன்" அப்படீங்குற படத்துல, அப்ப சன் டிவி ல டாப் டென் அப்படீன்னு கோட் சூட் போட்டுகிட்டு வசந்தன் பண்ணுற விமர்சனத்த அப்பவே சத்யராஜ் வாயால கிழிச்ச மாதிரி இப்ப இன்னோர் தடவ கிழிக்கணும்..
சரி இந்த நிகழ்ச்சி பற்றி அடுத்தவர்கள் என்ன நினைகிறார்கள் என்று தேடியபோது நிகழ்சிக்கு கிடைத்த வரவேற்புகள்...
balaji says:
March 19, 2010 at 12:00 pm
Programme is good but the comments of Judje (espically James Vasanthan) mentioned about parcipants profession is a stupid one and too much. he must mind his tounge when he gives his comment. If he dont wish to select he may simply say no, or can suggest or even say he didnt like, despite his comments irritates viewer’s and some participants too. Programme director may consider this in good way to assist Judges.
RAM says:
March 21, 2010 at 5:57 am
I completely agree with the above comments on these four judges.
I have been watching Jaya TV and find that these people behavior is something horrible. They have lot of attitude problem and they are insulting each every participant who comes and show their talents. The important point is, these four have not achieved any great heights in their career. My plea to Mr. Jamesh Vasanthan, do you thing that you had contributed enough in music. Please list down your great achievements and then insult people. The great Tippu Sir .. how many thousand songs you have sung so far. Mr. Dharani , please don’t sleep in the show .. wakeup man … don’t pull participant’s legs. Hello Madam Harini, look at Chitra, how compassionate she in Vijay’s TV’s show.
Request all four to watch Kalaignar TV’s “Vaanampadi” or Vijay TV’s Super Singer at least for ones and learn their mistakes.
I have great respect on Jaya TV and watched SPB’s Yennodu Pattu Padava, what a show it was. But my confidence and interest on Jaya TV has come down because of these Four judges.
With immediate effect at least in the next show, in an open forum these four judges should apologize openly. This is only way to earn the respect from the public… otherwise we should collectively STOP WATCHING “JAYA TV”.
Deepa says:
April 17, 2010 at 10:43 am
I accept with Ram’s message. I would like to tell that these people have not achieved much in their career and has no rights to insult others. Advice them to watch Super singer and vaanambadi.
Devavanitha says:
May 10, 2010 at 5:49 pm
James Vasanthan smiles so stupidly closing his eyes,and shows he is ‘ carried away ‘ by the music when Hariharanji sings and teaches the candidates.Very sycophantic. The only honest and sincere face on the stage is Hariharan’s own.James tries to ’supplement’ his comments, all uncalleed for. He should give way to a more seasoned judge , Hariji does not need any jaalra. Harini looks as uncertain as always, and seems to be floating in a world of her own.
Devavanitha says:
May 10, 2010 at 5:51 pm
James vasanthan need not supplement Hariji’s comments and ‘put’ jalraa and Harini needs to stop floating in a world of her own.
Devavanitha says:
May 10, 2010 at 5:54 pm
MY remarks are in general after Hariji came on the scene, and do not re;late to this one day’s performance, please note.
Muralidharan says:
June 17, 2010 at 8:46 am
Ram’s comment was absolutely right.
Mr.James Vasanthan should not insult the participant’s & to treat them like a shit. You should not question them that why they are standing here and all rubbish things. You people are don’t know how to respect the people. Just watch Vijay TV’s Super Singer Junior 2 the judges are giving respect to the children. Learn from Mr.Mano, Mrs.Chitra & Mrs.Shuba all the three & other judges are giving good respect to the childrens. Quit this show & watch Vijay TV
MADHANKUMAR says:
June 21, 2010 at 9:02 am
I have been watching Jaya TV and find that these people behavior is something horrible. They have lot of attitude problem and they are insulting each every participant who comes and show their talents. The important point is, these fellows have not achieved any great heights in their career. My plea to Mr. Jamesh Vasanthan, do you thing that you had contributed enough in music. Please list down your great achievements and then insult people. James vasanth he is not at all a talenter how that jaya Tv has selected him as a judge i dont know.Please ask him listem words of Dr. S.P.B Sir programme how he encouraging the contestants expects this programme all the programmes are good. what is his achievemnt just ask him to think, even i know about sharath but how he is like that in this programme. that three fellows are really want to destroy the name of Jaya tv. Mr. Hariharan is in the name of legent but his activities is not like that he use to comment the contestants with that fellows (My kind request to HARI MAKE UP IS NOT IMPORTANT IN THE WORLD, MAKE THE PERSON IS IMPORTANT IN THIS WORLD PLZ remember it)This is only way to earn the respect from the public… otherwise we should collectively STOP WATCHING “JAYA TV”. Please dont develop the inferiortity complex to the youngers. u Please quit the programme are the change programme title as “ASINGAPADA POVADHU YAAR”.
MADHANKUMAR says:
June 21, 2010 at 9:11 am
I have been watching Jaya TV and find that these people behavior is something horrible. They have lot of attitude problem and they are insulting each every participant who comes and show their talents. The important point is, these fellows have not achieved any great heights in their career. My plea to Mr. Jamesh Vasanthan, do you thing that you had contributed enough in music. Please list down your great achievements and then insult people. James vasanth he is not at all a talenter how that jaya Tv has selected him as a judge i dont know.Please ask him listem words of Dr. S.P.B Sir programme how he encouraging the contestants. expects this “haruyudan naan” programme all the programmes are good. what is his achievemnt just ask him to think, even i know about sharath but how he is like that in this programme. that three fellows are really want to destroy the name of Jaya tv. Mr. Hariharan is in the name of legend but his activities is not like that he use to comment the contestants with that fellows (My kind request to HARI MAKE UP IS NOT IMPORTANT IN THE WORLD, MAKE THE PERSON IS IMPORTANT IN THIS WORLD PLZ remember it)This is only way to earn the respect from the public… otherwise we should collectively STOP WATCHING “JAYA TV”. Please dont develop the inferiortity complex to the youngers. u Please quit the programme are the change programme title as “ASINGAPADA POVADHU YAAR”.
Bala says:
June 22, 2010 at 6:10 am
James vasanthan can you please telpl wat achievements you made in your life.Subramaniapuram intha orae padam padam vechutu how dare you talk this.You have no rights to sit as a judge.I agree Hariharan is a good singer but he is not a god >people sitting near him please dont put jalra to hariharan.The malayalam music director i dont know that guys name,bloody fellow even cant able to speak in tamil properly he is comenting and disrespects youngsters who tries to prove.If you three cant encourgae please dont discourage them them at the least.Your not even discouraging you three people disrespecting people,its not good.Jaya Tv has a good rappo among people .please try to maintain it and your TRP rate too.Please change the judges or stop the shows
naveenk says:
June 24, 2010 at 8:32 pm
James and sarath please use appropriate words to give your judgement and advice and dont spoil Hariji’s name. Only Hariji is giving constructive judgement and his advices are genuine. But sometimes we can sense his frustration. One advice for all participants from my side is, sharing a stage with legend like Hariji and singing with him must be a dream come true for any budding singer. After passing so many levels you all came to this level and you have to use this oppertunity fully and work hard.(To tell the truth kids in airtel super singer Junior at VTV sang some songs better than some of the contestants here) some of the lame excuses given by the contestants like yet to have food, most of the contestants said they have throat problems irritated viewers like us and hariji is spending his precious time pls make use of it. James and Sarath dont use harsh words and give respect to the contestants.
Gerard says:
June 27, 2010 at 2:30 pm
I wonder what’s happening in Tamil Nadu! Nobody speaks Tamil any more there? it’s really pity to see our precious language is on the verge of dissapearing from Tamil Nadu due to this English ego. Shame on you people.James, do us a favour will you? Please help us to save our mother tongue.
Tamil Canadian
sudharavi says:
June 29, 2010 at 3:45 pm
Actually what all said is correct. never hurt participants. It is absolutely true to watch spb sir’s show and also gangai amaran sir’s show’paadava un paadalai’ is also good.No persons are god to judge.Voices cannot be changed.They come hopefully and please dont discourage them.Also dont comment on others wounding by words.
venkatesh says:
July 16, 2010 at 4:31 pm
it is surprising and disgusting to see the main judge Hariharan sitting in a very wierd posture which reflects his personality as person whose headis too heavy.
Even great Elayaraja sir or A R Rehman S P etc are so humble in their behavior and body Language and speech. That’s the diference between a morn and a genius.
ashwin says:
August 9, 2010 at 6:20 am
hi … a nice program … i promise u tat daily im watching this … several times i ve told my mom tat i should ve learned singing after seeing this so tat even i can able to participate … really hari rocks …. just give me an opportunity to come and see the live shooting of this program … just in front of tv by telling my name please do give a hug to hari sir … any one can give it on my behalf , if they give i would be happy …. i do wish all the participant all the best …. james and sarath being there as a part of this program u both are lucky
ashwin says:
August 9, 2010 at 6:25 am
above ve mentioned about the wrong affairs of james … sir u doing ur job oly … u ve al rights to find fault … dont loose hopes by reading the above ones , u carry on … wat u doing is exactly right …. why must he find fault unless they dont sing properly … i like the singing of anush …..
raghav says:
August 14, 2010 at 7:08 am
hai all i am watching hariyudan nan regularly and i feel vanita and karthik are the best performers
Saigeetha karthikeyan says:
August 21, 2010 at 5:16 pm
hariyudan naan, onam special was really good. especially ‘pichai paathiram yendi vanden’ was very close to heart. the singer was so moved that he broke while ending it. james vasanthan was impressed and he comments, ‘paduda, you have all the emotion or whatever required for that song’ it is a heartfelt comment that’s ok, but how many guys would like that ‘da..’ from him, it,s doubtful. but sometimes i really doubt whether he is made to give harsh comments deliberately, so that the program invites much more attention? If it is so, then i feel really sorry for him for he has become the victim of such bad comments on him from the viewers of the show. He may not be able to perform on a stage but for a composer, he need not be a good singer. you should have music in you that’s all. from his comments i feet that he has got stuff, a lot of music. that’s great. we can’t expect a singer to be a composer and vice versa. ofcourse, exceptions are always there. But in onam special, unniji was the special guest and after his reasonable, positive comments over a singer james commented somewhat contradictorily to unniji’s comment, and that was a bit blunt and could have been more polished. hariji’s comments are always decent. but frankly it is sharath sir’s comments, sometimes i laughed and thank god i can never imagine myself receiving any such comments and i will never, because i am not a singer at all.
srividya says:
September 14, 2010 at 10:38 am
I have been watching this show regularly. I’m pretty upset with JAMES VASANTH’S behavior. He talks as though he has found music. He’s so rude and arrogant towards participants and also insulting THEIR GURUS, atleast Tipu sings and shows the participants once in a while but James is expert in insulting rather than music tat’s why he NEVER SINGS but ALWAYS INSULTS ALL THE PARTICIPANTS. The other unknown judge in the blue colour shirt doesn’t even look like he came from a musical background and i think he’s not qualified to be a judge. I think, because of James Vasanth’s influence Tipu and Harini are also rude and behaves like they are expert in music. I have a feeling that THESE 4 ARE “NETHU PEITHAY MAZHAILA INNUKU MOLACHA KALANS”. So I think these 4judges to be thrown away and some experienced and well mannered singers or music directors to be brought into this show. Generally music shows suppose to bring peacefulness and happiness but I’m very sorry to say after watching this show me and my family were really upset and felt like we were insulted and had a feeling of watching a very sad movie( as we are from musical family)- these four judges are black mark to music as well as film industry.
Aravindan says:
October 8, 2010 at 7:24 pm
You commenting peoples are telling that they don’t have any rights to scold contestents, because they didn’t acheived. So it means that they can insult the participants if they achieve. I completely regret this, eventhough juries achieved a lot they don’t have any rights to insult any contestent. Juries are appointed only to correct the participants not to insult them. All the four juries must learn atleast basic manners from SP Balasubramaniam sir. Balu sir is a peak. These peoples are nothing before him, both in talent & in behaviour. Intha
Aravindan says:
October 8, 2010 at 7:26 pm
Intha naalvarum garuda puranathinpadi thandikka padavendiyavargal.
rama says:
October 22, 2010 at 8:09 pm
they have disigned this program just like American Idol. In Americal idol, there is one harsh judge (Simon) and one soft one (Paula) and on medium who is Randy..so they have designed James vasanth to give harsh comments..
கருத்துகள் இல்லை:
கருத்துரையிடுக